October 14, 2025

Top Strategies to Win the Amazon Buy Box

Increase your sales on Amazon by winning the Buy Box! Learn valuable tips and tricks to boost your chances of winning this coveted spot and drive more sales. Read our guide now.
Top Strategies to Win the Amazon Buy Box
Top Strategies to Win the Amazon Buy Box

Key takeaways: 

  1. Over 80% of Amazon sales come through the Buy Box, making it essential for sellers who want to maximize visibility, sales, and revenue.
  2. To compete for the Buy Box, sellers must have a Professional Amazon Seller account, sell new products, maintain consistent inventory, offer efficient delivery, and uphold strong seller performance metrics.
  3. Using Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) significantly increases Buy Box chances since Amazon handles fast shipping and customer service, though FBM and SFP can still qualify with strong performance.
  4. Sellers who maintain competitive product pricing and high seller ratings (based on ODR, shipping, cancellations, and customer satisfaction) are more likely to secure the Buy Box.

Amazon has set itself as an undisputed leader in the ecommerce space with millions of products sold at low prices. 

Did you know that more than 80% of Amazon's sales come from the Amazon Buy Box? 

If Amazon FBA sellers must increase Amazon sales, understanding how to win the Amazon Buy Box is pivotal. 

This ePlaybooks article will tell you how the Amazon Buy Box works as well as some tips for Amazon Buy Box success.

What is the Amazon Buy Box?

The Amazon Buy Box is a critical component of the Amazon marketplace, located on the right side of a product page. It allows customers to easily add products to their cart or purchase them outright, marking the beginning of the checkout process.  

The Amazon Buy Box consists of the price of the product, shipping details, seller and fulfillment method, and “Add to Cart” and “Buy Now” buttons. On a desktop, you will find the Amazon Buy Box on the right side of the screen. On a mobile device, you will find it below the product image and product information. 

You will find that some products on Amazon have multiple sellers. In this scenario, these sellers will be competing for the Amazon Buy Box. So, Amazon will rotate the Buy Box between or among the sellers. 

Sellers compete for the Buy Box based on several criteria which we will look at shortly. Winning the Amazon Buy Box is crucial, as it can directly impact your sales and profitability. 

How does the Amazon Buy Box work? 

The Amazon Buy Box operates as a dynamic feature designed to enable quick and easy purchases for customers. Unlike other ecommerce platforms where a single seller occupies the primary purchase button, Amazon's Buy Box is shared among multiple top sellers for the same product, allowing customers to compare offers and choose the most suitable one. 

Amazon uses an algorithm to determine which seller(s) will occupy the Buy Box. This algorithm considers several factors, including price, seller performance metrics (like order defect rate, cancellation rate, and late shipment rate), and customer reviews.

The allocation of the Buy Box is dynamic and subject to change. Even after you secure the Amazon Buy Box, you must continuously strive to maintain your position due to the competitive nature of the algorithm.

Why is the Amazon Buy Box important? 

The Amazon Buy Box enables purchase and drives sales, making it an important component both for Amazon sellers and customers. Here are a few reasons why the Amazon Buy Box is essential: 

  • Increased sales: One of the most important reasons you should secure the Amazon Buy Box is to increase sales. Winning the Buy Box means that when customers click on the "Add to Cart" button, your product listing is the one added. This significantly increases the likelihood of making a sale, as most customers will use this button rather than browsing alternative sellers.
  • Improved visibility: Apart from increased sales, you will find the Amazon Buy Box prominently displayed on the product page, which means your listing gains more visibility compared to those of other Amazon sellers. This can lead to higher click-through rates and, consequently, more sales.
  • Buyer trust: If you win the Buy Box, it will show customers that Amazon considers you a reliable and trustworthy seller, which can enhance your reputation and encourage more purchases.
  • Efficient advertising: If you are using Amazon’s PPC (Pay-Per-Click) advertising, securing the Buy Box ensures that the traffic driven to your product page via ads is more likely to convert to your sales. If you do not win the Amazon Buy Box, your advertising spend might benefit your competitors instead.

How to become eligible for the Amazon Buy Box

Becoming eligible for the Amazon Buy Box involves meeting several criteria set by Amazon. Here are the key factors you should consider if you want to secure the Amazon Buy Box, double up sales and increase profits: 

  1. Professional Seller account: You must have a Professional Amazon seller account to be eligible for the Buy Box. So, if you are on the Individual selling plan, you will need to upgrade to qualify.
  2. Product availability: If you don’t have inventory, you will likely lose the Buy Box to your competitors. Your products need to be in stock. Amazon prioritizes listings with sufficient inventory to meet customer demand.
  3. Competitive pricing: This includes both the item price and shipping costs. Offering competitive pricing relative to other sellers can improve your chances of winning the Amazon Buy Box.
  4. Fulfillment method:some text
  5. Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA): Using FBA can significantly enhance your chances of winning the Buy Box because Amazon handles storage, shipping, and customer service, which generally leads to better fulfillment metrics.
  6. Seller-Fulfilled Prime (SFP): FBM sellers who meet Amazon’s high fulfillment standards and ship directly to Prime customers can also benefit.
  7. Merchant Fulfilled Network (MFN): If you decide to fulfill orders yourself, you must maintain excellent shipping performance and customer service to compete for the Amazon Buy Box.
  8. Shipping time: The amount of time it takes for a seller to ship an order to their customer is known as shipping time. This can have a high impact on winning the Amazon Buy Box. Faster shipping times can boost your chances of winning the Amazon Buy Box. Amazon prefers listings that offer quicker delivery to customers.
  9. Order Defect Rate (ODR): Your Amazon Order Defect Rate (ODR) includes three major metrics including negative feedback rating, A-to-Z Guarantee claims rate, and service chargeback rate. Amazon will look at these metrics to determine the number of defective orders. Amazon requires that you maintain a low ODR ( below 1%). To maintain a low ODR, you will need to ensure your product maintains high quality from production to delivery. You also want to ensure that your product listing provides accurate information to prevent customer dissatisfaction. 
  10. Seller Performance Metrics: Amazon considers several performance metrics, including:some text
    • Customer feedback rating: A high percentage of positive feedback over the past 30, 90, and 365 days. 
    • Order cancellation and refund rate: This includes the number of canceled orders before shipment and the number of refunded orders after shipment. You want to maintain a low cancellation rate no higher than 2.5%. 
    • Late shipment rate: This includes orders that were shipped after the expected ship date. Your orders should be shipped on time to avoid penalties and improve your chances of winning the Amazon Buy Box. You want to maintain a Late shipment rate of below 4%.
  11. Customer service quality: Providing prompt high-quality customer service contributes to higher seller ratings and better chances of winning the Amazon Buy Box.
  12. Sales volume and history: A strong sales history with consistent volume can enhance your eligibility, as it demonstrates reliability and customer satisfaction over time.
  13. Product condition: For new products, competition can be fierce. For used products, sellers with the best condition (like new) and competitive pricing have better chances of securing the Amazon Buy Box. 

How to win the Amazon Buy Box

Winning the Amazon Buy Box could be a bit more complex in practice. However, you can increase your chances of being awarded the most coveted spot on Amazon by employing a few Amazon FBA strategies. 

Here are a few Buy Box optimization techniques to help you win the Buy Box:

  1. Check your eligibility status
  2. Use Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA)
  3. Maintain competitive prices 
  4. Deliver fast shipping 
  5. Have good seller ratings 

Check your eligibility status 

To win the Buy Box, you need to first be eligible. As we've mentioned earlier, Amazon considers several factors for eligibility. 

Some of which include having a professional seller account, your selling metrics, and having available inventory. 

To check your eligibility status: 

  • On the inventory tab, click on “Manage Inventory
  • Next, click on Preferences and select Buy Box Eligible in the drop-down column.  
  • Lastly, Save Changes

Use Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA)

To drastically increase your chances of winning the Buy Box, consider using Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA). Here's why. 

For Amazon FBA sellers, Amazon handles everything from packing, shipping, and customer service. Ultimately, you can maintain perfect scores for Shipping Time and On-Time Delivery Rate. You also qualify to sell to Amazon Prime customers and offer fast shipping. 

You can still win the Buy Box with FBM and SFP. However, it may be difficult. Sellers need to have fantastic seller metrics among other factors to qualify to win the Buy Box. 

Maintain competitive prices 

Every customer loves to get quality products at the most affordable prices and Amazon makes this a priority. If you are competing to win the Buy Box, you simply cannot ignore pricing. 

The lower the prices of your product, the higher your chances of winning the Buy Box. However, the golden rule is to find the perfect balance between maintaining low prices while keeping your business profitable.

You can employ various pricing strategies for improving Amazon Buy Box performance. We will go through these pricing strategies in detail shortly. 

Deliver fast shipping 

Amazon will look at your shipping performance based on your projected shipping time and actual shipping time. 

Amazon FBA sellers have a great advantage here as Amazon handles the shipping. 

In general, Amazon evaluates shipping based on the following time frames:

  • 0-2 Days
  • 3-7 Days
  • 8-13 Days
  • 14+ days

To stay on top of your game, remember that your customers want free and fast shipping. You want to ensure customer orders get to them at the fastest possible time. 

Have good seller ratings 

Every seller has a rating. Amazon uses the 0-100 rating system to rate Amazon sellers. Amazon Seller ratings are based on several factors including: 

  • Order Defect Rate (Target = < 1%)
  • Negative Feedback Rate
  • Filed A to Z Claim Rate
  • Service Chargeback Rate
  • Return Dissatisfaction Rate (Target = < 10%)
  • Negative Return Feedback Rate
  • Late Response Rate
  • Pre-Fulfillment Cancel Rate (Target = < 2.5%)
  • Late Shipment Rate (Target = < 4%)
  • Refund Rate
  • Valid Tracking Rate, etc. 

Amazon monitors each of these metrics and favors sellers with a high seller rating. As an Amazon seller, it is important to keep an eye on these metrics and ensure you stay on top of your game.

Amazon Buy Box pricing strategies 

Amazon sellers are constantly optimizing their prices to gain a competitive advantage. For some sellers, only a few cents can make all the difference. 

Here are three main pricing strategies for optimizing your prices on Amazon: 

  • Manual repricing
  • Rule-based repricing
  • Algorithmic repricing 

Manual repricing

Manual repricing is a strategy that involves manually setting your prices by looking at competitors’ products and adjusting SKUs. You can do this through your Amazon Seller Central account or third-party platforms. This method gives you control over your prices. However, it can be an impossible task if you have a large portfolio. 

Manual repricing works best for sellers who sell few products, make their own products, or do not have much competition. 

Rule-based repricing

Rule-based repricing is one of the most widely used pricing strategies. It is common with automatic repricing tools and involves setting your own parameters. 

With this strategy, you can change prices while ensuring you maintain a good profit margin. You can set parameters to ensure your profit margin never drops below 10%. You can also set conditions where your prices drop below the lowest-priced competitor. 

To get the most out of the rule-based repricing strategy, ensure they are set to meet your business needs. 

One disadvantage of rule-based repricing is that it can lead to price wars between sellers, affecting overall profitability.

Algorithmic repricing

Algorithmic repricing tools use machine learning to come up with their own set of rules to help you win the Buy Box and maximize profitability. 

These tools take into account several other factors apart from price to find the perfect spot between winning the Buy box and maintaining profitability.

If you have a large portfolio, the Algorithmic repricing strategy may work best for your business. However, algorithmic repricing tools can be expensive. 

The Suppressed Buy Box 

A Suppressed Buy Box on Amazon is when the "Add to Cart" and "Buy Now" buttons disappear from a product listing, replaced by a "See All Buying Options" link. 

This happens when Amazon determines that none of the sellers meet its criteria for winning the Buy Box, typically due to factors such as uncompetitive pricing, lack of sales history, decline in account health metrics, violation of price parity across channels, low sales volume, and so on. 

So, when customers click on “See All Buying Options”, they are taken to a webpage with offers sorted from the lowest to the highest prices. Amazon does this to encourage customers to consider all available options to pick the best possible deal. 

Amazon Buy Box myths

Several myths surround the Amazon Buy Box, leading to confusion among sellers about how to effectively compete for it. Read on as we debunk some of these myths, so you can secure the Amazon Buy Box and increase Amazon sales. 

Myth 1: The lowest price always wins

Securing the Buy Box does not solely depend on price. Amazon's algorithm considers several factors including price competitiveness, seller rating, shipping speed, order defect rate, product availability, and other factors. 

Myth 2: The Buy Box can be owned or controlled

Some people believe that the Amazon Buy Box is owned or controlled. Well, this is far from the truth. The Amazon Buy Box is very fluid and cannot be permanently owned or controlled. Its allocation changes frequently and unpredictably, reflecting Amazon's continuous efforts to optimize customer experience and maintain competition. 

Myth 3: Doing everything right guarantees winning the Amazon Buy Box

This is a common myth among Amazon sellers. Despite following best practices, the reality is that you may not win the Buy Box due to the dynamic nature of Amazon's algorithms and the presence of other competitive offers. Sometimes, the offer in the Buy Box may not necessarily be better than others. Random right? Well,  Amazon incorporates some randomness to ensure fairness and prevent manipulation. 

Amazon Buy Box percentage 

The Buy Box percentage tells you how many times your listed item shows up in the Amazon Buy Box compared to the total page views. 

For example, if you have 10,000 page views for your products and your product appears in the Buy Box 500 times, your Buy Box percentage would be 5%.

Theoretically, if four sellers are selling a particular product with similar performance metrics and pricing, they should have a Buy Box percentage of 25%. 

How to optimize your pricing to secure the Amazon Buy Box

While price is not the only factor Amazon considers for selecting an Amazon Buy Box winner, it is one of the most important factors you need to consider. Here are strategies you can employ to help you win the Amazon Buy Box. 

  • You want to offer prices that are either the lowest or very close to the lowest among competing sellers. This includes accounting for shipping and handling costs. However, while offering competitive prices is crucial, it's essential not to sacrifice your profit margins in a race to the bottom. Find a balance that allows you to remain profitable. You can use repricing tools like BQool and RepricerExpress to ensure your prices remain competitive at all times. 
  • Monitor your pricing strategy and adjust as needed based on market trends. Use data to fine-tune your pricing and test various pricing strategies and fulfillment methods to find what works best for your business. 
  • Use Amazon's Seller Central dashboard and third-party analytics tools to monitor key performance indicators such as price competitiveness and customer feedback to identify areas of improvement. 
  • Manual repricing can be an effective strategy for small businesses or sellers with a limited product range. Although time-consuming, it allows you to control your pricing decisions and respond quickly to changes in the market. Manual repricing can be effective in niche markets where competition is less intense. 

See also: What Sellers Should Know About Amazon Pricing Strategies

Final thoughts 

With the majority of sales coming through the Amazon Buy Box, winning the magic Buy Box can increase Amazon sales and revenue. To win the Buy Box, ensure you meet all eligibility requirements and maintain high performance on Amazon. 

At ePlaybooks, we guide our clients with proven strategies and insights to help improve their chances of consistently winning the Buy Box and maximizing their Amazon success.

Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

How do you win the buy box on Amazon?

To win the Buy Box, you need to meet Amazon’s eligibility requirements and maintain strong performance metrics such as competitive pricing, fast shipping, and great customer service. 

How does Amazon decide who gets the buy box?

Amazon uses its algorithm that considers factors like price, fulfillment method, seller performance, shipping speed, and inventory levels. Sellers who perform best across these areas are more likely to secure the Buy Box.

How to increase sales through Amazon?

You can increase sales on Amazon by optimizing your product listings, running Amazon ads, leveraging reviews, driving external traffic (social media, blogs, etc), offering competitive pricing, and using fulfillment by Amazon for your orders.

Can I make $1000 a month selling on Amazon?

Yes. Many sellers make $1,000 or more each month, but it depends on factors such as product selection, pricing strategy, marketing, and inventory management.

Turbo-Charge Your Revenue!

You’ve probably already considered selling on Amazon but its way easier than you think.

Call Us Now

Enjoying our articles?

Subscribe to our newsletter to receive ePlaybooks insights directly in your inbox. Don't worry we will respect your inbox.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.